Pick Your SITE You Want TO Review The FX5900U or The R9800P

[john19055]

Because some of them favor the Nvidia FX5900Ultra in a big way ,and other sites Favor ths Radeon 9800pro in a big way. So to me it's really a toss up,I just can't believe that there is that big of difference in different reviews.So if Nvidia is your thing then go for it ( just the price is the Killer),but if ATI is your thing ,then go for it,you really can't go wrong with either one,they both perform pretty damn well.

[reever2]

beyond3d

[Sazar]

Originally posted by reever2
beyond3d

seconded but I don't want dave to be called a fanboy if he does a fair and thorough review and doesn't show one card or the other having a big advantage...

[john19055]

I useally by Nvidia but this time I think the Radeon 98000PRO is the better deal ,cheaper in price and in most reviews it wins ,but not all,but nearly all say the IQ is betterI went from a TI 4600 to a R9800pro and there is a big difference,IQ is clean.

[The Baron]

*you might see both here soon ;) *

[digitalwanderer]

www.elitebastards.com , who else? :p

(B3D, nVnews, DH, & R3D I pretty much trust too. ;) )

[extreme_dB]

I want to see detailed user reviews in these forums! Benchmarks, subjective comments, overclocking, notable problems...the whole experience in the first few days of ownership and the impact of the upgrade. :)

[Sazar]

Originally posted by digitalwanderer
www.elitebastards.com , who else? :p

(B3D, nVnews, DH, & R3D I pretty much trust too. ;) )

my goodness... do you pimp your site enough :)

lol.. I mean seriously for a tiny site like that you make it seem like its one of the big players out there :D

gg m8... lol..

/me designates digi as EB's official cheerleader... pom-pom's and all...

[extreme_dB]

Originally posted by digitalwanderer
www.elitebastards.com , who else? :p

(B3D, nVnews, DH, & R3D I pretty much trust too. ;) )

How would you rank those sites in order of personal preference? :)

[B&R]

Firingsquad which they already did(reviews i.e).

[digitalwanderer]

Originally posted by extreme_dB
How would you rank those sites in order of personal preference? :)
For reviews? Probably:
B3D
EB
DH
nVnews
R3D

[The Baron]

Aw, c'mon, you'd rather see somebody besides me? :p

[GlowStick]

To anyone who cares!

I rank my reviews as

2Cpu
Nvnews
Anandtech

I just dont like that the little guys that dont get mega hits each day get screwed on getting free hardware.

And i also hate review sites that have 'reviews' that are like one page. EG. i read a mouse pad review that pritty much said "this pad is good, it works with optical mice, i recomend this pad"

where you can tell they are bsing, and just got the free product, wrote a cuple words endourcing it and boom publish it.

[Hanners]

Originally posted by digitalwanderer
www.elitebastards.com , who else? :p

* Grabs the pop-poms off Dig *

Absolutely, 100% correct! :afro2:

Now, who wants to send me a 5900 Ultra to review over there? ;)

[john19055]

WROTE ON WRONG THREAD,I was thinking I was on the Anti-Detection thread,that digitalwanderer did (I know I should have payed better atention of what thread I was on) , I thought it would have been better if more games were used to see the difference in benchmarks between the FX5900 u and the R9800 p instead of just 2001se mark or 2003 mark,don't remember witch one he used.

[muzz]

B3D would be my first choice.
Then:
NVNews
R3D

The 2 guys from [H] without Kyle getting involved........:D