PDA

View Full Version : am i the only one that thinks Doom3 > 3dM2k5 game1 ?


Nv40
10-08-04, 04:12 AM
have been "playing" with 3dmark 2005 for some time..and while its very nice ,to my surprise is doesnt match the quality i have seen in Doom3..at times. when you compare it to Game1. while shadows are softer ,and levels have more polygons , im conviced that Doom3 could have done that scene which far better quality. there are quite some big level in DOom3 that completely surpass the quality of 3dmark05 game1 :D a still you get far better performance :)

game3 is the only one that really i liked .. even though there are games with better water .. still looks pretty nice the test. apart from the flickering shadows that happens no matter if you use DST or not.

at the moment have been impressed with Doom3 graphics more than any other game or benchmark this year ,Farcry comes second :D

after seein 3dmark05 ,im even more impressed today with D3 engine. :)

BioHazZarD
10-08-04, 04:43 AM
yeah because 3dmark is not a game only a benchark, i agree doom3 is much much better.

SH64
10-08-04, 06:19 AM
Well i think it might be true only to some aspects .

the GT1 has larger draw distance & better particle effects all over the scene .

DaveW
10-14-04, 02:43 PM
I think Doom 3 is better because it doesn't artifact all over the place, unlike 3DMark 2005

Ninjaman09
10-14-04, 02:56 PM
I think Doom 3 is better because it doesn't artifact all over the place, unlike 3DMark 2005
No kidding, I couldn't stand that. It's ridiculous. That's with everything at stock, too.

Kojiro
10-19-04, 04:05 PM
I don't get artifacts in 3dmark 05.

3Dmark mark cinemas are better looking than those gay tech demos that nvida have.

I love ATI's Ruby demo.

I play Doom 3 all the time at 1200X1024 at High qality with 4x AA.

I say that all of you guys should get your eyes checked, 3dmark 05 is what could only be done in pre rendered layers, like how they make 3d movies like Shrek and Finding Nemo, a couple of years back. Now hardware is power full enough to do it in real time. That is very impresive if you know what real time is.

GamerGuyX
10-19-04, 06:43 PM
That is very impresive if you know what real time is.

We would have to be idiots to not know what "real time" is. :screwy:

saturnotaku
10-19-04, 06:59 PM
3DMark 05 - real time graphics straight out of a cat's a** hole.

aaahhh52
10-19-04, 08:09 PM
3DMark 05 - real time graphics straight out of a cat's a** hole.
w3rd

einstein_314
10-19-04, 11:03 PM
I don't get artifacts in 3dmark 05.

3Dmark mark cinemas are better looking than those gay tech demos that nvida have.

I love ATI's Ruby demo.

I play Doom 3 all the time at 1200X1024 at High qality with 4x AA.



Watch what you say man. We don't want to start a flame thread do we? We all have our own opinions.

holmes
11-01-04, 11:01 PM
There's artifacts in 3Dmark05? Never seen any.. although I do use the 61.77s. Oh, and I agree that Doom3 does at times look just as good as 3Dmark05.

Intel17
11-02-04, 11:45 AM
have been "playing" with 3dmark 2005 for some time..and while its very nice ,to my surprise is doesnt match the quality i have seen in Doom3..at times. when you compare it to Game1. while shadows are softer ,and levels have more polygons , im conviced that Doom3 could have done that scene which far better quality. there are quite some big level in DOom3 that completely surpass the quality of 3dmark05 game1 :D a still you get far better performance :)

game3 is the only one that really i liked .. even though there are games with better water .. still looks pretty nice the test. apart from the flickering shadows that happens no matter if you use DST or not.

at the moment have been impressed with Doom3 graphics more than any other game or benchmark this year ,Farcry comes second :D

after seein 3dmark05 ,im even more impressed today with D3 engine. :)

That's John Carmack magic for ya! I agree, Doom3 looks absolutely stunning, technically and visually!

FarCry is second, but still feels like a game ;)

majortom
11-02-04, 11:47 AM
3dmark is purely a benchmark tool. the main point is to throw out as much dx eye candy as your vid card can handle.