nV News Forums

 
 

nV News Forums (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/index.php)
-   NVIDIA GeForce 200 Series (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/forumdisplay.php?f=60)
-   -   GTX 280 OR Not (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=114991)

Topboy 06-18-08 08:42 AM

GTX 280 OR Not
 
Hi All

Ok here is my dilemma.

I purchased a EVGA 9800 GX2 SSC Edition 5 days ago.

I have just spoken to the retailor who has said I can return it for an RMA as its within 7 days and this is the returns policy.

Question is -

1. Do I keep the 9800 GX2 considering the reviews and benches it is winning against the 280

OR

2. Do I send the 9800 GX2 back, get a GTX280 and purchase another GTX280 in the future when the drivers are settled in.

Im looking for longevity here.

Do you think this card will shine once the drivers are settled in?

Thanks for your help :thumbsup:

Topboy

brady 06-18-08 08:50 AM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
Send that GX2 back and get a 280. You don't want the headaches of SLI.

GeeTeeEx 06-18-08 09:02 AM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by brady (Post 1685296)
Send that GX2 back and get a 280. You don't want the headaches of SLI.

very true.

Topboy 06-18-08 09:26 AM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by brady (Post 1685296)
Send that GX2 back and get a 280. You don't want the headaches of SLI.

What headaches in SLI.

Im thinking of getting 2 GTX280s to replace my 9800 GX2

K007 06-18-08 09:34 AM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
Make sure what eva review you visit...get the min fps information. I noticed a few sites where they are showing the results the avg fps is higher on the GX2...but its min fps is suffering alot due to only having 512MB of ram...THE GTX280 is targeted at people on high ress with AA..so yes the GX2 is gonna have some issues with its 512MB of ram..and you will suffer from stuttering and low fps due its ram limitation...the GTX280 will shine on that..and i would say..

If you HAD to buy a GX2...i think a GTX260 might be a better choice. but if u want to decide between the two..i say GTX280...its good..but its price is high...

The GX2 is defiantly not future proof.

brady 06-18-08 09:36 AM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
Don't forget about microstutters. So far as I know the gt200 SLI generation is the only one to finally squash that nasty under-reported little bug.

Maverickman 06-18-08 01:45 PM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
I have a post about this very subject. I bought a 9800 GX2 to try it out in my system. My GTX 280 should be coming soon. Soon I'll know for sure about how beneficial that 1GB of RAM will be. My monitor has a native resolution of 1920X1200, and I like to use AA and AF, so the GTX 280 will be the better card for my uses. If you have a 30-inch monitor you'll definitely see a huge improvement with the GTX 280. It crushes the 9800 GX2 at that resolution. There are two main features the GTX 280 has going for it: It's 1GB of dedicated video memory and the 512-bit memory bus. These features can be helpful in today's games in high resolutions with AA and AF enabled, but they will really come in handy in future games that will definitely tax the card's memory subsystem. That's why the 8800 GTX still does well against the 9800 GTX in memory bandwidth-intensive games. It has that 384-bit memory and 768GB or onboard RAM.

grimreefer 06-18-08 01:51 PM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
current games- 9800gx2 is better.
future games - a bit of a gamble, but gtx 280 might be faster
cuda apps- gtx 280 is better
ppl are citing alot of things without evidence.
read the anandtech article and come to your own conclusion.
heres a taste: http://images.anandtech.com/graphs/g...3021/17060.png

Blacklash 06-18-08 04:05 PM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
If you're a single GPU guy get a GTX 280. If you want SLi I would think two overclocked GTX 260s would be enough for anything. The latest cards are really going to shine 1920x and up with AA piled on. I've used multi-GPU, SLi and Crossfire. Even when my GTX has put up lower numbers than the other methods metioned the FPS has been much smoother. I'd expect the GTX 280 to be even better. With the other methods I'd get odd glitches, hitching and wild FPS fluctuations. Also at some point 256Mb interface cards with 512Mb memory will run out.

Example-
http://img228.imageshack.us/img228/8...2560barkt5.jpg

I'd prefer SLi over Crossfire because nVidia have more than one method of AFR. When standard AFR doesn't work in a title with Crossfire you are left with worse than a single card performance. At that point you may disable it to get back to single level of performance.

Revs 06-18-08 04:10 PM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
GTX280 for a little future proofing. 2xGX2(quad SLI) nothing like as good as 2x GTX280(SLI). Quad SLI just doesn't scale well.

Roliath 06-18-08 04:54 PM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by brady (Post 1685296)
Send that GX2 back and get a 280. You don't want the headaches of SLI.

I don't think SLI is all that bad, its just on the GX2 its weird. I didn't really ever have compatibility issues when I briefly had a 8800GTX sli, nor back in the with the 7900GTX's.
Just with the GX2, its different..

Send the GX2 back FAST, and get the GTX280..

Dual Core Joe 06-18-08 04:56 PM

Re: GTX 280 OR Not
 
How does the 9800 GX2 stand up against two 8800GTX's in SLI?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:47 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 1998 - 2014, nV News.