nV News Forums

 
 

nV News Forums (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/index.php)
-   Gaming Central (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   EA exec warns against suing file-sharers (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=118324)

Vik1dk 08-22-08 02:31 PM

EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
Isnt that a new tune from EA..(lee)
http://www.gamesindustry.biz/article...g-file-sharers

CaptNKILL 08-22-08 02:42 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
Wow...

EA just keeps pulling out more surprises.

They may actually dig their reputation out of the crapper if they keep up with stuff like this.

I completely agree that suing 0.01% of the pirates for ludicrous amounts of money will do absolutely NO good for the industry.

Vanzagar 08-22-08 03:07 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
I don't even understand how they track these people down, how can they be sure a certain IP address is downloading their content, then beyond that how can you be sure which person it is that lives in a house, could be five guys sharing a computer in a house? Does this stuff actually make it to court, and if so, I wonder how much money they are fined, the cost of the game or some huge amount like a half a mil....

Mr.Schme 08-22-08 03:46 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
scare tactic

LurkerLito 08-22-08 03:55 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
They are right to not sue really. All it will do is make the average guy more curious as to how and where to get it for free and it'll all go down hill after that. It wasn't till Metallica started suing their fans and the pirates that Napster went from popular service for the geeks and semi-geeks to anyone with a net connection grabbing tunes. I can see the same thing happening here.

Kaguya 08-22-08 04:14 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Vanzagar (Post 1753930)
I don't even understand how they track these people down, how can they be sure a certain IP address is downloading their content, then beyond that how can you be sure which person it is that lives in a house, could be five guys sharing a computer in a house? Does this stuff actually make it to court, and if so, I wonder how much money they are fined, the cost of the game or some huge amount like a half a mil....

They collect the IP addresses from those seeding torrent files, for example, then they subpoena the ISP for records on who was using that IP address at the time of the infringement. 99% of the time the ISP receives a complaint and either they contact the user to tell them to stop, or they do nothing.

CaptNKILL 08-22-08 04:21 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
If I download a torrent I can see the IP address of anyone I'm connected to.

Its pretty easy to find someone this way assuming you have enough clout or legal power to get information out of the ISP.

Whoever has their name on the internet bill is the one who gets in trouble.

With so many unsecured networks out there these days, it just makes it even more difficult.

Son Goku 08-22-08 04:35 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
In a manner of speaking; if things had gone the sueing route (outside the fact that many recipients can be in countries for which US courts have no legal jurisdiction, or power to coerce someone to appear); if things went such a strong arm tactic, some could design as "feature" clients which spoof an IP address while allowing an internal mapping (on an over-seas server in a country with no legal responsibility to appear to a US court) to deliver it to the right place. The logs could be routinely purged, and not archived for posterity.

:rofl The days I was taking network security. We had classmates, who for some class assignments had the idea of turning a class assignment into a spoofed telnet server, which looks legit to point of asking for username and password (it wasn't one, and no real login); and then just let people to a command prompt on any input, while logging whatever they typed to a text file for latter viewing.

Hell, it was the suites of Napster which resulted in things going to a more distributed and de-centralized approach. Almost proxy servicing the IPs/mapping them out, while spoofing fake ones to be displayed to clients/put in the download tracker would be sorta a next logical step to that. And if the mapping file is routinely purged, so old mapings don't persist in record...

shabby 08-22-08 04:38 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kaguya (Post 1754026)
They collect the IP addresses from those seeding torrent files, for example, then they subpoena the ISP for records on who was using that IP address at the time of the infringement. 99% of the time the ISP receives a complaint and either they contact the user to tell them to stop, or they do nothing.

And if ea takes the ip owner to court, how will they prove he did the actual downloading? Based on assumption?

tornadog 08-22-08 06:21 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
I am on strike 2 from my ISP for using torrents. One more and they will disconnect my connection. But lately they have been lenient in the use, since I guess everybody is using it these days(legally or otherwise)

$n][pErMan 08-22-08 07:25 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
I always have to reset my modem after like 12+ hours of torrent use... kind of annoying but easy to do :)

CaptNKILL 08-22-08 07:39 PM

Re: EA exec warns against suing file-sharers
 
What ISPs do you guys have?

Mine never gives me any problems.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:20 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 1998 - 2014, nV News.