nV News Forums

 
 

nV News Forums (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/index.php)
-   NVIDIA Linux (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/forumdisplay.php?f=14)
-   -   Word from Nvidia on HDMI audio disabling? (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=156664)

chmmr 10-30-10 05:37 PM

Word from Nvidia on HDMI audio disabling?
 
Several people have had a problem similar to mine (documented here) in which analog audio is ignored by a TV because it's getting an empty audio signal over the HDMI connection (DVI adapter or no) that serves the TV video: example A, example B.

There are two workarounds for this problem that are tedious, risky and only comprehensible to very advanced users: 1) disable EDID from xorg.org conf and provide a custom modeline that tells the TV how to display properly, and 2) hex-edit an extracted EDID to disable the TV's understanding of an HDMI audio signal.

This problem affects Windows users as well, and Nvidia support issued a fix in the form of the Vista-specific "DLP hotfix" utility.

It has been brought up before, but I'm wondering if Nvidia ever intends to provide some user-visible, preferably user-friendly way of disabling the HDMI audio output of its video cards. One of the folks in that thread I linked emailed linux-bugs@nvidia.com, but I'm assuming nothing was done about it, because that was two years ago and there have been several major driver releases since then. Aside from my specific problem, there are several legitimate reasons a user would want to do this.

When I bought my card (a Gigabyte GT 240), the HDMI audio wasn't even mentioned anywhere on the box or in the manual. It was only when I upgraded to Ubuntu 10.10, and a new version of ALSA / Nvidia drivers caused the audio device to start half-working, that I started to have this problem. One concern is that less experienced users (the kind Ubuntu seems to be reaching out to) or Windows switchers will assume this convoluted situation is a Linux/Ubuntu problem, when in fact it's a TV (Samsung in my case, and they've repeatedly told people to consult their video card maker) problem and an Nvidia problem.

I realize the Nvidia Linux drivers don't touch sound at all, but it's still their hardware / software, so it would be nice to hear if they are aware of the problem and if so what they intend to do about it.

I'm happy to provide more info if needed. Thanks!

dura91 10-31-10 12:08 PM

Re: Word from Nvidia on HDMI audio disabling?
 
Have you tried to disable the snd_hda_codec_nvhdmi module ? If this works it's more user friendly than manipulating EDID.

DeiF 10-31-10 04:11 PM

Re: Word from Nvidia on HDMI audio disabling?
 
This single thing is the only one that keeps me from still needing to manually edit xorg.conf.

chmmr 10-31-10 05:17 PM

Re: Word from Nvidia on HDMI audio disabling?
 
Quote:

Have you tried to disable the snd_hda_codec_nvhdmi module ? If this works it's more user friendly than manipulating EDID.
Yes, I did try that, and it had no effect other than the expected - the HDMI audio device stopped appearing in Pulseaudio / ALSA's list of available devices.

primerib 10-31-10 06:36 PM

Re: Word from Nvidia on HDMI audio disabling?
 
I don't see how this is an Nvidia problem. If your tv maker didn't consider these situations, or it wasn't cost-effective to implement, or lack of demand then I guess more research should have been put into finding a tv that suits your needs.

Also, I don't see any real problem with disabling EDID in xorg.conf. I know several linux (htpc) newbies who have managed to come up with working modelines for their tv/monitors so to say doing this is "tedious, risky and only comprehensible to very advanced users" simply isn't true. From what I've seen, most average users seem to get it figured out just fine.

In all honesty I can't imagine it's more then a small handful of people wanting HDMI video coupled with analog audio in the first place.

Have you tried routing your analog output through the Nvidia audio device? Do you actually _need_ analog audio for some (outdated) reason?

Stephen Warren 11-02-10 11:39 AM

Re: Word from Nvidia on HDMI audio disabling?
 
We do have a bug filed to attempt to solve this issue.

chmmr 11-03-10 01:16 PM

Re: Word from Nvidia on HDMI audio disabling?
 
Fantastic, thank you.

chmmr 07-16-11 03:20 PM

Re: Word from Nvidia on HDMI audio disabling?
 
Dunno if this has been looked into any further yet. I still have this problem in Ubuntu 11.04 with the 270.41.06 drivers.

http://techgage.com/news/disabling_n...o_under_linux/

"The best possible fix for this problem would be for NVIDIA to allow the disabling of HDMI audio (this wouldn't affect the video) inside of its control center."


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:23 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 1998 - 2014, nV News.