nV News Forums

 
 

nV News Forums (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/index.php)
-   Gaming Central (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   Valve decide what fps is OK (http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=35170)

svetli_pp 08-20-04 01:04 PM

Valve decide what fps is OK
 
I've read that the stress test of HL2 runs DX8.1 path on all FX cards. Its absolutely ridiculous. I have 5900XT and see that at 1024x768 it runs the test 92fps. Isn't it normal to be able to turn DX9 render path and get lets say 40-50 fps. Everything concerning HL2 benchmarking is very stinky I think. ATI is pushing Valve to deliberately adjust the performance in order to close the gap Doom3 dug between two card manufacturers. I'm sure it won't happen, because HL2 is not half as demanding a game as Doom, and lacking 10% will not make it unplayable on highest settings 1600 where 6800U makes 60fps. If when the game is done and released FINALLY:) Valve do not allow my card to run it DX9 I officially announce I will never even try it. I don't like first HL much either. All the fuss around HL2 benches now reminds me of the same situation last year. Hope the following events will not resem :lame: ble last year's and we'll see the game at last.

Sazar 08-20-04 01:09 PM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
?

how is their trying to maximise the frame-rate with the minimum of IQ loss a bad thing?

would it not SUIT ati and valve if per your insinuations they were out to hurt nvidia if they had just run the stock dx9 path for the FX series and seen the frame-rate plummet?

in light of the fact that the benches do indeed show pretty good performance for the FX series (a little faster than the r3xx series in raw fps though w/o running dx9 path) it becomes very suspect to accuse valve of trying to hurt nvidia here...

do you have and proof to back your claims of ati pushing valve to deliberately hurt nvidia? last i checked the performance of nvidia cards on the source benches was pretty good..

DaveW 08-20-04 01:36 PM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
Its funny how people compared the HL2 engine against Doom 3. Its nowhere near as advanced. I've said it many times and nobody listens...

The HL2 engine is a hack the QUAKE ONE engine.

Its just a rebuild of the original Half-life engine (which was based off Quake 1, NOT Quake 2), and it has the havoc physics engine taped onto the side. Download the leaked source and see for yourself. First line in the code is "#include glquake.h".

The only reason the HL2 screenies look so good is because they can use higher resolution textures and poly counts with todays cards. The HL2 screens appear to use a lot of real world photos for the buildings etc and they do look very sweet, but the engine itself is nothing special. This is why we are seeing 100+ FPS. And yeah, ATI cards are faster than nVidia... but if I get 100 FPS instead of 120 FPS I don't care. I won't notice the difference, unlike with Doom 3 where I would be getting 25 FPS instead of 45 FPS if I got a x800 Pro instead of a 6800 GT. At lower frame rates the performance difference is much more important.

The HL2 engine will still be a good base for mods because of its lower requirements. The game may still be good because of the story and level design. It will look good because of good modelling and excellent texturing. But the engine itself is nothing special.

Assi9 08-20-04 02:10 PM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
So because "#include glquake.h" is included in the code, so automatically, Source = Quake 1 engine?

Wait a minute, my name is George W. Bush, that means I must be the president of the United States!!! :clap:

Rakeesh 08-20-04 02:42 PM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveW
Its funny how people compared the HL2 engine against Doom 3. Its nowhere near as advanced. I've said it many times and nobody listens...

The HL2 engine is a hack the QUAKE ONE engine.

Sorry, but that is very dumb logic. It would be like saying that a Ferrari is the same as a peice of **** dodge neon since the frame is made out of the same kind of metal, and some of the nuts and bolts are the same size.

gmontem 08-20-04 03:52 PM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
I feel like renaming one of the header files at work "glquake.h" now. :p

gmontem 08-20-04 03:57 PM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
Oops I meant it to read '... at work to "glquake.h" now.' Hmm, strange how post editting has been disabled.

Holy Smoke 08-20-04 06:40 PM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
Anyone wanna bet there's no trace of earlier Quake engines in Doom3?

If you turn off shadows, bump mapping and specular, it looks REMARKABLY like a low poly Quake3, leading to the possibility that that's exactly what the doom3 engine is.

Holy Smoke 08-20-04 06:47 PM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
Also, the Tenebrae mod for the original Quake seems to back that up, as it's just based on the it's source code, with additions.

http://tenebrae.sourceforge.net/shots8/quake00066.jpg
http://tenebrae.sourceforge.net/shots8/quake00099.jpg
http://tenebrae.sourceforge.net/shots8/quake93.jpg
http://tenebrae.sourceforge.net/shots8/quake00006.jpg
http://www.tenebrae2.com/screenshots...tb-base_06.jpg

Rakeesh 08-20-04 08:56 PM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
quake1 models are teh sux :D

|JuiceZ| 08-20-04 11:11 PM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
Are there any high rez text mods for q2?

Cheimison 08-21-04 01:57 AM

Re: Valve decide what fps is OK
 
"Are there any high rez text mods for q2?"
Yes, I believe it's enhanced Q2

Doom 3's graphics engine beats Half-Life 2 easily, but HL2 seems to have more work put into their textures and map details (probably because you couldn't see it in Doom 3 anyways). Also, unless you're running a machine similar to mine, if you tried to put a Doom3 level engine into fully lit gameplay with large, outdoor areas(like a lot of HL2 will probably be) your framerate would plummet into unplayability.

HL 2 also seems to have better physics, plus Valve said it supports GeoModding


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:55 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 1998 - 2014, nV News.