Played Everquest 2 for the first time...
...and it was much better than I was expecting. I guess since WoW seems to be dominating the charts and everyone is talking about the newer MMO's coming out (Vanguard, LOTR-O), I thought the EQ2 experience would reflect its popularity. The graphics were great as expected (7800GS & FX-53), but there were a lot of other things about it that surprised me and kept me interested.
I'm guessing that either 1) the gameplay wasn't as polished at release and it turned people away or 2) the system requirements were too high when it was released and not enjoyable given the hardware available at the time. Or maybe its something else? What do people not enjoy about this MMO?