View Single Post
Old 04-22-07, 04:23 AM   #2
Mr. Hunt
Rectal Gravy Connoisseur
Mr. Hunt's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Texas
Posts: 8,294
Default Re: Lots of HD questions

Originally Posted by nrdstrm
Sorry to do this, but I'm somewhat unfamiliar with alot of this stuff, and will be buying soon (next few months, possibly sooner). I've already asked about TV's, and will probably be getting a 42"-50" LCD with Native 1080P Support (Verizon Fios TV is going to start broadcasting sports in 1080P in the fall!!! WOOT!) I know I can search the net, but I trust you guys more than some guy I don't know on a forum I don't visit. Now to the questions...

1. I know this is a HUGE debate, but could someone who owns both Blu-Ray and HD-DVD explain the pros and cons of each (without being overly fanboyish? :P)

2. If I choose Blu-Ray, I might opt for the PS3 (I hear it's a good player). Do the games they make for it run at a high resolution though? (IE-High Def)?

3. If I choose HD-DVD and buy a cheapy one, is that bad? Are there any inexpensive ones that are decent out there? How is the $199 add on unit for the 360? I might go that route..

4. If I choose to go balls out and buy a combo unit - is there anything wrong with this one :
I know it doesn't do iHD, but what is that anyway?

5. Do either format have movies that are 1080P? If not, why are people buying 1080P TV's (With exception of Fios like I stated above)

6. Would it be best to wait it out and just buy an upconverting DVD player? How do those look compared to BR or HDDVD? BestBuy has an LG on sale for 85 bucks!

Thanks in advance - I won't be able to see any responses till Tuesday as I'll be out of town, so don't be put off if I don't answer any ? during that time..
1.) Studio support for Blu-Ray is much greater than HD-DVD. (EDIT: IMHO)
2.) PS3 games are 720p minimum as far as I know.
3.) No experience on the 360 add-on, but I have read reports that it has sound issues and cannot pass the lossless tracks.
4.) iHD is the interactive function on some HD-DVDs... like PiP stuff I believe... as far as I know it would only mean you couldn't watch certain bonus features.
5.) Both are 1080p (though I believe the Toshiba A1 and A2 only output at 1080i, but I could be wrong). Sometimes studios release them in 1080i though (only heard about this regarding Nine Inch Nails and Bikini Destinations on Blu-Ray... but there could be more or I could be wrong).
6.) Upconversion 99% of the time is no match for a real HD source.

EDIT: Just making sure people don't act like a dick because of my first answer... had to put in IMHO so I don't state it as gospel.
Mr. Hunt is offline   Reply With Quote