View Single Post
Old 01-13-08, 09:03 PM   #41
Registered User
Ruined's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 2,447
Default Re: Blu-ray vs. HD DVD (an in depth analysis)

Originally Posted by Gaco
Most online reviewers and really hifi savy people find MPEG4 AVC slightly superior to VC-1. If anybody wants a link or two I can try and dig them up but I consider this more common knowledge.
MPEG4 AVC and VC-1 are virtually the same thing at the bitrates they use on Blu-Ray and HD DVD. Given the same care, there will be no difference between the two. Some editors, such as the inept Dan Ramer of DVDFILE, have made erroneous conclusions on codecs based on completely different movies and genres; comparing the average video review scores of movies like Liar Liar, Daylight, and The Jerk to Pirates of the Carribean and Meet the Robinsons - then blaming the disparity on the codec instead of the master. Pretty laughable stuff, I would pay them no mind. Then of course enthusiasts on various websites who are anti-MS will preach AVC night and day because of their hatred for Microsoft; again, pay them no mind - we are not comparing companies, we are comparing codecs and encoders.

At very low (i.e. 56k modem) bitrates, though, MPEG4 AVC may have an advantage. But that is irrelevant in this discussion.

Another thing to consider is that the Microsoft professional VC-1 encoder is awesome, but it is the only VC-1 encoder that exists so there isn't much choice. There are various AVC encoders and some of them are worse than others. Only a select few come close to the MS VC-1 encoder.
We're all in it together.

Intel Core 2 Quad Q6700 2.66GHz CPU | Intel G965WH mobo | 8GB (4x2GB) DDR2-667mhz CAS5 RAM (1066MHz FSB) | BFG GeForce 285 GTX OC 1GB | Dell E228WFP 22" DVI-HDCP LCD Monitor | 1TB Western Digital RE3 SATA2 Main Drive | 500GBx2 Western Digital RE3 SATA2 Scratch Drives in RAID0 | Western Digital RE3 1TB SATA2 Media Drive | External 2TB Western Digital MyBook Backup Drive | Adaptec eSATA 3.0gbps PCI-E interface | Sandisk External 12-in-1 Flash Card Reader | LG GGC-H20L HD DVD/BD reader, DVD writer | LG GGW-H20L HD DVD/BD reader, DVD/BD writer | Microsoft E4000 Ergonomic Keyboard | Logitech Trackman Wheel | Antec P182 ATX Case | Thermaltake ToughPower XT 850w modular PSU | KRK RP-8 Rokit Studio Monitors | Windows Vista Ultimate x64
Ruined is offline   Reply With Quote