You could include Crysis in that. People bashed that game night and day. Hell, you get bashed if you post a million screenies e.g. Soetjuret
Jericho is only $9.99 on steam. Tempted?
Ye gods, Far Cry 2 is only $19.99 on steam! Another maligned game in some forums.
i7-2600k, Xspc rs240, Asus Maximus IV Gene-z, 8gb G.Skill DDR3 1866 RIPJAWSX CL7, PoV GTX 670, Corsair HX1000W, 128GB Vertex 4, WD 1tb Caviar Black, 500 & 320gb Seagate