I played this and finished it in one night. Not worth the asking price on AU Steam, but I had fun, it's not deserving of the bad press it's getting. Especially the far superior PC version.
I guess it's a game for fans of Duke only. For me I was like watching the Johnny Bravo cartoon. You either get the humour or not. I love how much of a Dumbass Duke is, it's like he really struggles, but makes it anyway. Actually if you are a fan of The Bigman you'll enjoy this game :