Re: Mass Effect3, Alan Wake or Skyrim ?
Skyrim, hands down. Especially now that it's been all patched up.
Mass Effect 3 is really good, despite the crying about the ending. It's about a 30 hour game max, I finished it in 21 hours or so. I have more than double that in Skyrim.
I have Alan Wake for the 360 and although it was good, it would be my 3rd choice.