Originally Posted by Vardant
Out of those listed, Dragon Age would be my first pick, followed by Amalur.
Otherwise, if you have missed and are not afraid of playing older titles, then Planescape Torment's story will probably blow you away. And then you will have plenty of games to follow that up.
Amalur is great fun. I need to play Planescape too. I have it on GoG, but keep ignoring it. :