View Single Post
Old 08-17-02, 08:45 PM   #1
savyj
Registered User
 
savyj's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2002
Posts: 97
Default AMD 2400+ and 2600+ Benchmark Extrapolations

I decided (based on my other post asking whether or not AMD could temporarily take back the flagship crown from Intel) to try to extrapolate some data on the matter. Based on Anandtech's Athlon XP 2200+ review (http://www.anandtech.com/cpu/showdoc.html?i=1635&p=1) which pitted the XP 2200+(KT333) against the Northwood P4's with RDRAM (PC1066). I ran the numbers and this is what I came up with.

Calculations based on:
NVIDIA's claim for the nForce2 to beat KT333 performance by "at least a few percent". "A few" is generally defined as a small number usually between 3 and 5. For these tests, I used 3.

I graphed out the average percent increase per 66mhz increase in Athlon XP speed (based on the Anandtech numbers) and for sake of efficiency loss, ROUNDED DOWN. Therefore if the average was a 3.68% increase per 66mhz increase I used 3% for my calculations.

DISCLAIMER: These are simple math EXTRAPOLATIONS. Do NOT make purchase decisions based on these numbers, they WILL NOT necessarily resemble the actual benchmark numbers of the shipping products (once shipped :-)

SYSMark2002 O.P. - Athlon XP increased 2% per 66mhz increase
2600+/nForce2=177
2600+/KT333=172
2400+/nForce2=170
2400+/KT333=165
P4-2.53/850E=178

SYSMark2002 I.C.C. - Athlon XP increased 3% per 66mhz increase
2600+/nForce2=278
2600+/KT333=270
2400+/nForce2=262
2400+/KT333=254
P4-2.53/850E=330

Lame MP3 Encoder - Athlon XP decreased 3% per 66mhz increase
2600+/nForce2=1.48
2600+/KT333=1.52
2400+/nForce2=1.57
2400+/KT333=1.62
P4-2.53/850E=1.65

Adobe After Effects - Athlon XP decreased 3% per 66mhz increase
2600+/nForce2=12.1
2600+/KT333=12.5
2400+/nForce2=12.9
2400+/KT333=13.3
P4-2.53/850E=10.1

3D Studio MAX - Athlon XP increased 4% per 66mhz increase
2600+/nForce2=71.2
2600+/KT333=69.1
2400+/nForce2=65.9
2400+/KT333=64.0
P4-2.53/850E=57.1

Maya 4.0.1 - Athlon XP increased 4% per 66mhz increase
2600+/nForce2=71.2
2600+/KT333=69.1
2400+/nForce2=65.9
2400+/KT333=64.0
P4-2.53/850E=57.1

The two Lightwave 7.5 Benches - P4 wins both
(I didn't do these because the optimizations for the P4 are so extensive the Athlon XP CAN'T catchup without SSE2).

Unreal Perf. Test - Athlon XP increased 3% per 66mhz increase
2600+/nForce2=59.8
2600+/KT333=58.1
2400+/nForce2=56.2
2400+/KT333=54.6
P4-2.53/850E=50.0

Jedi Knight 2 - Athlon XP increased 3% per 66mhz increase
2600+/nForce2=134.1
2600+/KT333=130.2
2400+/nForce2=125.4
2400+/KT333=121.7
P4-2.53/850E=116.6

Commanche 4 - Athlon XP increased 4% per 66mhz increase
2600+/nForce2=54.4
2600+/KT333=52.8
2400+/nForce2=50.8
2400+/KT333=49.3
P4-2.53/850E=51.2

That's 11 tests total - here's the total
Athlon XP - 6 wins (including all 3 games)
P4 - 5 wins (mostly SSE2 optimized media tools)

If you use +5% instead of +3% for the nForce2 equations, the Athlon XP 2600+/nForce2 combo takes one addtional test (SYSMark2002 I.P.) away from the 2.53ghz P4.

If these results turn out to be true, it seems that AMD would indeed take back the flagship performance crown (just barely). That is, until Intel ships the 2.66ghz P4
savyj is offline   Reply With Quote