5328 not working while 4496 were ok

[zebul999]

hello,
whith the same config the 4496 were working quite well.

But the 5328'one don't work:
i have got a black screen after X starts and in the XFree*.log the error
(EE) No screen found

and even problem with the virtual console that don't scroll anymore when X is started. All is ok before.

Config:
debian woody 3.0r2 kernel 2.4.24 (ftp.kernel.org)
Atlhlon XP 1800+
Geforce 4 Mx 440 (0x0171)
MotherBoard: AsRock KTVT2 with via chipset
Screen:Acer 77e
no /dev/agpd
and no modeline in XFreeConfig but it is ok with 4496

So what are the big changes between 4496 and 5328 ???

[zebul999]

after a little investigation in /vaR/log/syslog
it seems to be the problem
----------------------
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: Oops: 0000
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: CPU: 0
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: EIP: 0010:[pci_read_config_dword+18/64] Tainted: P
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: EFLAGS: 00013046
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: eax: 00000048 ebx: 00003246 ecx: 00000048 edx: 00000000
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: esi: 00000000 edi: c12e5c00 ebp: cdd13738 esp: cdd13704
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: ds: 0018 es: 0018 ss: 0018
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kdm[4249]: Server for display :0 terminated unexpectedly
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: Process XFree86 (pid: 4254, stackpage=cdd13000)
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: Stack: cff2bc00 00003099 d093761a 00000000 00000048 cdd13734 cdd1373c 00000002
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: 00003099 cdd1373c d094668e cfcf3000 00000000 cdd13748 d095123d 00000000
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: 00000048 cdd13774 d0949856 cff2bc00 00000000 00000048 00000800 cd8c8000
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: Call Trace: [<d093761a>] [<d094668e>] [<d095123d>] [<d0949856>] [<d094d127>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d094eae0>] [<d0ae9420>] [<d095558e>] [<d0936c19>] [<d0ae9420>] [<d0b129cc>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d0b129f0>] [<d0b12a08>] [<d0b12960>] [<d0ae9420>] [<d0a1d48d>] [<d0952fcc>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d0ae9420>] [<d0b129cc>] [<d0b129f0>] [<d0b12a08>] [<d0ae9420>] [<d0956179>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d0ae9420>] [<d0a1df5f>] [<d094668e>] [<d0951188>] [<d0ac1c71>] [<d0952b4b>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d0ac1c71>] [<d0ac1c71>] [<d0952b9c>] [<d0aeab20>] [<d0a1cc4b>] [<d0969848>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d09770dd>] [bh_action+26/80] [tasklet_hi_action+70/112] [<d0a1cd8b>] [<d0946d8a>] [<d09382cb>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d0946f15>] [<d09526f2>] [<d0ae9420>] [<d09e3f97>] [<d0a1d0af>] [<d0a1cd8b>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d0a1cd8b>] [<d0a1cd8b>] [<d0a1cd8b>] [<d0a1d48d>] [<d0a65b00>] [<d0a0b5c8>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d0a39a77>] [<d09ff1a3>] [<d0ae9420>] [<d0ae9420>] [<d0a00df1>] [<d0956cf9>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d0a00cb5>] [<d0959a72>] [<d09526f2>] [<d0ae9420>] [<d0944eab>] [<d0a01534>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d0a0142b>] [<d0ab997c>] [<d0936d7e>] [<d0ae94b4>] [<d0aeac18>] [<d0955561>]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [<d0ae9420>] [<d0935a4b>] [<d0ae9420>] [<d0ae9420>] [fput+188/224] [sys_ioctl+601/624]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: [system_call+51/56]
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel:
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: Code: 8b 46 10 8b 50 30 8b 44 24 14 50 51 56 8b 42 08 ff d0 83 c4
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: <1>Unable to handle kernel NULL pointer dereference at virtual address 00000010
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: printing eip:
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: c01ce282
Jan 6 10:47:33 mimas kernel: *pde = 00000000
_______

so http://www.sh.nu/download/nvidia/linux-2.4/ seems to correct the problem.
i 'm gonna try that.

And i wonder if the output of lspci is ok with the unknown device or haven't I forgot to compile something in the kernel ?

01:00.0 VGA compatible controller: nVidia Corporation: Unknown device 0171 (rev a3)

[zander]

lspci uses a regular file to match PCI ids to product names; the man page should tell you where that file lives (/usr/share/misc/pci.ids on Debian GNU/Linux).

[zebul999]

thx zander
i have updated my pci.ids
and lspci show a nice Geforce Mx 440 now.

(still not tried the www.sh.nu drivers)